Feeling Tied Up Trying to Organize Your Manufacturing Business?
Imagine this: Your business is growing, and orders are coming in faster than ever. It should be exciting, right? But instead, you find yourself drowning in spreadsheets. Each new order means another update, another sheet to sift through, and another late night at the office. You’re stuck spending hours making sure everything on the manufacturing floor runs smoothly. It’s frustrating, tedious, and it’s holding you back.
What if we told you there’s a way to make this whole process more efficient and way less stressful? A secret that could change the way you run your business—freeing you from the constant struggle of manually managing everything? Let us introduce you to MRP systems.
The Secret to Effortless Manufacturing Management
MRP stands for Material Requirements Planning, but we like to think of it as a superpower for manufacturers. With an MRP system, you can automate and streamline inventory and production tasks, eliminating those endless spreadsheets and manual updates. Picture this: instead of constantly updating sheet after sheet, you have a system that automatically keeps track of all your materials, schedules production, and manages inventory levels. Suddenly, your job becomes less about tedious details and more about growing your business.
We’ve done the work for you—digging deep into different MRP systems, reading through customer reviews, and talking to real users. The result? A carefully curated list of the top 10 MRP systems that can help streamline your manufacturing process. This guide is specifically crafted for small and mid-sized businesses with revenue up to $50 million. If you’re looking to take control of your manufacturing, keep reading.
What is an MRP System, Really?
In simple terms, an MRP system is a tool that helps manufacturers track everything they need to make a product—from raw materials to components and sub-assemblies. It’s like having an assistant that not only tracks what you have in stock but also predicts what you’ll need and when you’ll need it. With MRP, you’re always prepared, and production runs like a well-oiled machine.
Think of it as your behind-the-scenes production planner—always calculating, adjusting, and optimizing so you don’t have to. An MRP system can help increase productivity by managing key aspects like existing inventory, reordering low items, and scheduling processes. It’s all about reducing lead time, improving inventory management, and freeing you up to focus on bigger things.
Key Features of MRP Software
Before diving into the best MRP software options, let’s talk about what makes an MRP system effective. Not every system is created equal, and depending on your needs, some features might be more important than others. Here’s what to look for:
Bill of Materials (BOM): Tracks all raw materials, components, and assemblies along with quantities needed to create parts and products. Imagine being able to easily see everything that goes into your finished product in one place.
Inventory Management: This feature monitors and controls stock levels, ensuring you have the right amount of material to meet customer demands. No more surprises or emergency orders—just smooth, efficient production.
Order Management: Efficiently organizes, tracks, and fulfills customer orders, making sure nothing slips through the cracks. This means happier customers and fewer headaches.
Production Scheduling: Uses customer trends and forecasts to ensure all necessary supplies are available. It’s like having a crystal ball that helps you make sure you’re always ready.
Reporting/Analytics: Evaluates reports for material picking in work orders and keeps an eye on key metrics. This means more data-driven decisions that push your business forward.
Supply Chain Management: Helps plan and execute everything from raw material procurement to production and delivery. It’s like having a map to navigate your entire supply chain effortlessly.
User-Friendly Interface: An MRP system should be easy to use, with intuitive navigation that doesn’t require an IT expert. You need something that works for you, not something that adds to your stress.
Customization: The software should be flexible enough to fit your specific needs, whether it’s customizing dashboards or adapting workflows. Every business is unique, and your MRP should be too.
Scalable: Your business is growing, and your software should be able to grow with you. Scalability is key for long-term success.
Cost-Effective: Finally, it’s important to find software that fits your budget while offering the functionalities you need for a good return on investment.
Is It Time to Upgrade Your MRP System?
It’s easy to get comfortable with the systems you’re used to, but outdated MRP software can hold your business back. Here are some signs it’s time to upgrade:
Scalability Issues: If your current system can’t keep up as your business grows, it’s time for a change.
Outdated Technology: If your system feels clunky or outdated, there are better, more modern options available.
Poor Integration with Other Systems: If your MRP doesn’t play well with other tools you use, you’re missing out on efficiency.
Lack of Customization and Flexibility: Your business is unique, and if your software can’t adapt to your specific needs, it’s not serving you well.
Limited Reporting and Analysis Capabilities: If you can’t easily pull the data you need, you’re missing opportunities to optimize and grow.
If any of these sound familiar, it’s time to evaluate your MRP system and consider upgrading to a more suitable solution. The right software can help your business thrive and grow, instead of holding you back.
Ready to Find the Right MRP System?
We know how overwhelming it can be to sort through all the options out there, so we’ve done the work for you. Our list of the top 10 MRP systems is designed to help small and mid-sized manufacturers find the perfect fit for their needs. With the right tools, you’ll be able to streamline operations, boost productivity, and focus on growing your business—without the stress of spreadsheets and manual processes.
So, are you ready to level up your manufacturing game and find the MRP system that will help you do just that?
What are the best MRP softwares available?
Now that you know the standard qualities required in MRP software, you can choose the best system that is suitable for your business requirements from the following list:
Overview Brahmin Solutions is a powerful and comprehensive MRP system designed specifically for small to mid-sized manufacturing businesses. It provides a centralized, user-friendly platform that manages production, inventory, sales orders, and supply chain operations seamlessly. With advanced features and real-time data analytics, Brahmin Solutions helps businesses streamline their processes, boost productivity, and gain a competitive edge in the market. Its focus on providing intuitive, scalable solutions makes it an ideal partner for SMBs seeking operational excellence without complexity.
Key Features
Comprehensive Product Management: Effortlessly manage complex product lines, including variants, kits, and bundles, providing full control from start to finish.
Industry-Specific Expertise: Solutions tailored for industries like food, brewing, health and supplements, cosmetics, and personal care, ensuring all unique industry needs are met effectively.
Seamless Integrations: Integrates smoothly with a wide range of third-party applications, including accounting software, CRM systems, ERP tools, e-commerce platforms, and logistics providers, enhancing overall workflow efficiency.
Advanced Batch Tracking: Offers robust batch tracking capabilities, ensuring full compliance and visibility, particularly crucial for industries managing perishable goods.
Strategic Production Planning: Enables efficient production scheduling and provides complete visibility of the entire production process, from raw materials to finished goods, empowering informed decision-making.
Customer Support & Service Brahmin Solutions sets the benchmark for customer support in the MRP industry, providing a level of service that truly differentiates it from competitors:
In-House Support Team: Unlike competitors that outsource support, Brahmin Solutions has a dedicated in-house team committed to customer success.
Rapid Implementation: With expert guidance, customers are set up 2 to 3 times faster than other solutions, allowing for a quick and efficient transition.
Multi-Channel Support: Assistance is available through phone, email, or live chat, ensuring help is always readily accessible.
Personalized Guidance: From initial setup to ongoing use, the support team provides tailored assistance, ensuring that each business's unique needs are met comprehensively.
Customization & Integration Brahmin Solutions provides flexible workflows that can be tailored to fit the unique requirements of any manufacturing industry. Its seamless integration with popular third-party tools, including accounting, CRM, ERP, e-commerce, and shipping/logistics platforms, ensures that the software blends effortlessly into existing business processes, creating a unified and efficient operational environment.
Pros
Exceptional In-House Support Team: Available through multiple channels for a consistent, high-quality support experience.
Guided Implementation: Quick and efficient setup thanks to a dedicated in-house implementation team.
End-to-End Traceability: Full visibility into all aspects of the manufacturing process ensures compliance and operational transparency.
Flexible Workflows: Adaptable workflows cater to the specific needs of various manufacturing industries, providing a personalized experience.
SMB-Focused Design and Pricing: Affordable pricing tailored for small to mid-sized businesses, making it accessible and highly relevant for growing companies.
Cons
Mobile App in Development: Currently lacks a mobile app, though one is actively being developed.
Primarily Focused on SMBs: Designed specifically for small to mid-sized businesses, which may not suit larger enterprises with more complex requirements.
User Feedback Users consistently praise Brahmin Solutions for its:
Intuitive Interface: Easy to navigate, significantly reducing the learning curve compared to other MRP solutions.
Responsive and Knowledgeable Support Team: A dedicated team that understands user needs and provides prompt, effective assistance.
Ease in Handling Complex Manufacturing Processes: Powerful tools to manage even the most intricate manufacturing workflows.
Customization Options: Tailored features that cater specifically to industry needs, ensuring that unique business requirements are met.
Robust Reporting and Analytics: In-depth reporting capabilities that provide valuable insights, helping businesses make data-driven decisions.
Brahmin Solutions is more than just an MRP software—it's a dedicated partner in business growth. With its combination of advanced features, seamless integration capabilities, and unparalleled customer support, Brahmin Solutions is the ideal choice for SMBs looking to optimize their manufacturing processes. The company's commitment to customer success is evident in every aspect of their service, from implementation to ongoing support, setting Brahmin Solutions apart from other MRP systems. If you're seeking an MRP solution that not only meets your business needs but actively supports your growth, Brahmin Solutions is the clear choice.
2. Fishbowl Manufacturing
Pricing: $2,145 / Year per user Implementation Costs: $4,000 - $10,000 Free Trial: 14 days
Overview Fishbowl Manufacturing is a popular choice for small to mid-sized manufacturers needing basic inventory and production capabilities. It provides some useful features, such as barcode scanning and custom reports, but falls short in terms of modern capabilities and ease of use.
Key Features
Barcode Scanning: Helps track inventory but lacks real-time syncing capabilities.
Automatic Reorder Points: Can set reorder levels, though it's not always as dynamic as other modern solutions.
Bespoke Reports: Offers customizable reports, though users often report difficulty navigating the options.
Production Scheduling: Provides basic tools for managing work orders and tracking labor, but not as comprehensive or intuitive as leading solutions.
Customer Support & Service Fishbowl Manufacturing’s customer support is often cited as one of its weaker aspects. Users have reported issues with timely resolution of problems, and much of the support relies on email or phone, which can be cumbersome. Unlike more advanced MRP providers, Fishbowl does not offer a dedicated in-house implementation team, making setup more challenging for users without technical support.
Pros
Light MRP System: A simple solution for those new to MRP, offering just enough features for smaller operations.
QuickBooks Integration: Its integration with QuickBooks can be beneficial, although not always seamless.
Affordable for Basic Needs: The pricing makes it an accessible option for those with limited requirements.
Cons
Outdated User Interface: The interface is not very user-friendly and feels dated, leading to a steeper learning curve.
No Real-Time Sync with QuickBooks: Syncing delays can cause issues for those relying on up-to-date data.
Limited Customer Support: Support can be inconsistent, and users often find it hard to get complex problems resolved quickly.
Not Cloud-Based: Unlike modern solutions, Fishbowl is server-based, which limits remote access and scalability.
User Feedback While Fishbowl Manufacturing provides the essential features for small manufacturers, users frequently mention its outdated technology, lack of real-time syncing, and limited support as major downsides. The server-based nature of the software is also a disadvantage for companies that want the flexibility of cloud-based access.
3. Netsuite
Pricing: Base price is $999 / Month Implementation Costs: $25,000 - $100,000 (Implementation done only via partners) Free Trial: None (Product Demo available)
Overview NetSuite is a comprehensive cloud-based ERP and MRP solution designed for large and complex organizations. While it offers a wide range of functionalities such as financial management, inventory control, and procurement optimization, its implementation can be challenging, time-consuming, and expensive. These factors, combined with its complexity, make it a less suitable option for small to medium-sized businesses.
Key Features
Financial Management: Offers robust tools for accounting, budgeting, and reporting, ideal for enterprises with extensive needs.
Inventory Control: Provides advanced inventory tracking, but its complexity can be overwhelming for companies seeking simpler solutions.
Procurement Optimization: Powerful procurement tools are available, but implementation and customization can be costly and time-consuming.
Customization & Integration
NetSuite is known for its extensive customization options, allowing it to fit the unique requirements of large enterprises. It integrates well with various third-party systems, providing a flexible solution for diverse business operations. However, these customization options often require substantial time, expertise, and cost, making it unsuitable for companies looking for a straightforward, out-of-the-box solution.
Implementation Challenges
High Costs: Implementation costs ranging from $25,000 to $100,000 are prohibitively expensive for many organizations, especially SMBs.Time and Resource Intensive: Successful implementation often requires dedicated internal resources or expensive external consultants, straining both financial and human resources.Partner-Dependent Implementation: NetSuite's implementation is only available through third-party partners, leading to inconsistent quality and potential additional costs.Data Migration Issues: Many organizations face significant challenges related to data quality and integrity during implementation.
Customer Support & Service
Customer support is one of NetSuite's more frequently criticized aspects. Basic support is included but often limited, and users must pay extra for premium support. Unlike some competitors that provide direct, in-house support and guided implementation, NetSuite's partner-based approach can complicate onboarding and ongoing support.
Pros
All-in-One Solution: Ideal for enterprises needing a comprehensive platform encompassing ERP and MRP features.
Robust Financial Management: Strong accounting, budgeting, and financial analysis capabilities.
Cons
Expensive Implementation and Subscription Costs: High base costs and implementation expenses make it inaccessible for most SMBs.
Complexity and Steep Learning Curve: Challenging to manage without specialized support.
Limited Customer Support: Additional support packages required for comprehensive assistance.
Not SMB-Friendly: Better suited for larger enterprises due to pricing, complexity, and lack of direct support.
User Feedback
Reviews from platforms like G2, Capterra, and GetApp frequently praise NetSuite for its depth of features and integration capabilities. However, users commonly note the challenges in implementation and the extensive learning curve, particularly for smaller teams. The reliance on external partners for support and customization makes the process less predictable, which can be frustrating for users who need consistent and immediate help. Small and mid-sized businesses often struggle with the high costs and complex setup, making NetSuite a less favorable choice compared to more agile and budget-friendly solutions.
4. MRP easy
Pricing: Starts at $49.00 per month per user Implementation Costs: $0 (Uses partners for implementation; additional charges may apply) Free Trial: 30 days
Overview MRPeasy is a cloud-based MRP solution designed for small and medium-sized manufacturers seeking an affordable way to streamline production processes. It offers features such as inventory management, production planning, and purchasing within an easy-to-use platform. While it's marketed as an ideal solution for small businesses looking for a straightforward, scalable, and budget-friendly MRP system, user experiences reveal some challenges that potential customers should consider.
Key Features
Inventory Management: Provides tools to track and manage stock levels, though some users report limitations in handling complex inventory scenarios.
Production Planning: Facilitates production scheduling and work orders, but may struggle with highly complex manufacturing processes.
Purchasing: Manages procurement processes, although some users note difficulties with more advanced purchasing workflows.
Mobile Accessibility: Offers mobile apps for both Android and iOS, enabling on-the-go management, which is generally well-received by users.
Customization & Integration MRPeasy offers some customization options, but they are more limited compared to enterprise-level solutions. While it integrates with popular accounting software and e-commerce platforms, users have reported challenges with more specialized integrations or when dealing with multiple third-party systems.
Implementation Challenges
Self-Service Approach: The lack of a dedicated implementation team can be challenging for users without technical expertise.
Data Import/Export Issues: Some users have faced difficulties in importing large amounts of data or exporting data in specific formats, which can be time-consuming during setup.
Learning Curve: Despite being designed for ease of use, many users report a significant learning curve, especially when setting up complex manufacturing processes.
Customer Support & Service MRPeasy offers basic support options, primarily through email and a knowledge base. Users have reported mixed experiences with customer support:
Response Times: Some users have experienced slow response times, especially for more complex issues.
Limited Support Channels: The lack of phone support is a common complaint among users needing immediate assistance.
Knowledge Base Reliance: Users often need to rely heavily on the platform's knowledge base for troubleshooting, which may not always address specific issues.
Pros
Affordable Pricing: Starting at $49 per month per user, it remains one of the most budget-friendly options available.
Suitable for SMBs: Offers appropriate functionality for small to medium-sized manufacturers without overwhelming complexity.
Mobile Accessibility: Mobile apps enable on-the-go management, adding flexibility for users.
Cons
Limited Customization: Lacks advanced customization options, which can be problematic for businesses with unique workflows.
Reporting Limitations: Some users find the reporting capabilities to be basic, lacking depth and customization options.
Scalability Concerns: As businesses grow, MRPeasy may struggle to keep up with increasingly complex operations.
User Feedback Users generally appreciate MRPeasy for its affordability and core functionality tailored to small manufacturers. The visual dashboards and mobile accessibility are frequently praised. However, several challenges are consistently mentioned:
Implementation difficulties, especially for those without technical expertise
A steeper learning curve than expected, particularly for complex manufacturing processes
Limited customization options for unique business needs
Integration challenges with specialized or multiple third-party systems
Basic reporting capabilities that may not meet advanced analytical needs
Concerns about the system's ability to scale with growing business complexity
Inconsistent experiences with customer support, particularly for complex issues
Despite these challenges, many users still find MRPeasy to be a valuable tool for small manufacturers, especially those transitioning from manual processes or basic spreadsheets to a more structured MRP system. However, businesses with complex operations or rapid growth plans may need to carefully consider whether MRPeasy can meet their long-term needs. For companies seeking a more advanced solution with direct support, Brahmin Solutions stands out as a better alternative, providing personalized assistance, scalability, and comprehensive features to ensure manufacturing success.
5. Katana MRP
Pricing: Starts at $179.00 / Month - $1,999 / Month Implementation Costs: $0 - $1,499 (Uses partners for implementation; additional charges may apply) Free Trial: None (Product Demo available)
Overview Katana MRP is a modern manufacturing and inventory management solution designed for small and scaling businesses. It offers real-time tracking, seamless integration, and innovative features to streamline operations for efficient production and inventory control. While it provides valuable functionality for many manufacturers, user feedback highlights both strengths and challenges that potential customers should consider.
Key Features
Real-time Inventory Management: Provides live insights into stock levels, though some users report limitations with complex inventory scenarios.
Manufacturing App: Facilitates production scheduling and shop floor management, which is generally well-received by users.
Multi-Location Support: Offers inventory tracking across multiple locations, but this feature is limited in lower-tier plans.
Order Fulfillment: Manages sales orders and purchase orders, though some users note difficulties with advanced purchasing workflows.
Customization & Integration Katana offers integrations with popular e-commerce, accounting, and shipping platforms. However, some users have reported challenges with more specialized integrations or when dealing with multiple third-party systems. API access is available in higher-tier plans, but users have noted limitations in API request rates.
Implementation Challenges
Partner-Dependent Implementation: While Katana offers implementation services, the quality can vary depending on the partner.
Data Migration: Some users have reported difficulties in importing large amounts of data or exporting data in specific formats.
Learning Curve: Despite being marketed as user-friendly, many users report a significant learning curve, especially for complex manufacturing processes.
Customer Support & Service Katana's customer support receives mixed reviews:
Responsiveness: While some users praise the support team's responsiveness, others report slow response times for complex issues.
Knowledge Base: Users often need to rely heavily on the platform's knowledge base for troubleshooting.
Ongoing Development: Katana seems responsive to user feedback, with many reporting that feature requests are considered for future updates.
Pros
Intuitive User Interface: Praised by many users for its ease of use.
Shop Floor App: Provides real-time production management capabilities.
Traceability Features: Enables tracking of materials and products for better visibility.
Responsive to User Feedback: Feature requests are considered for future updates.
Cons
Aggressive Price Increases: Long-term customers report significant price hikes, sometimes 2-3x within two years.
Limited Functionality for Wholesale: Lacks features specific to wholesale businesses, making it less ideal for those in that market.
Restricted Kitting Capabilities: Limited ability to manage kits, which can be problematic for businesses requiring complex kitting.
No Drop Shipping Functionality: Missing a drop shipping feature, which is critical for some manufacturers.
Scalability Concerns: May struggle to meet the needs of rapidly growing businesses.
User Feedback Users generally appreciate Katana for its core functionality and user-friendly interface. However, several challenges are consistently mentioned:
Unexpected and Significant Price Increases, causing some long-term customers to seek alternatives.
Implementation Difficulties, especially for businesses with complex manufacturing processes.
Limited Customization Options for unique business needs.
Concerns About Scalability with growing business complexity.
Mixed Experiences with Customer Support, particularly for complex issues.
Despite these challenges, many users still find Katana MRP to be a valuable tool for small to medium-sized manufacturers, especially those transitioning from manual processes or basic spreadsheets to a more structured MRP system. However, businesses with complex operations, rapid growth plans, or specific needs like wholesale or drop shipping may need to carefully evaluate whether Katana can meet their long-term requirements. For businesses seeking a more scalable and support-focused solution, Brahmin Solutions stands out as the superior choice, offering a robust set of features designed to accommodate growth and complexity without compromising on personalized support or affordability.
6. Odoo
Pricing:
One App Free: Available for all users.
Standard Price: Starts at $24.90 per user per month for all apps. Implementation Costs: $493 - $25,000 (Uses partners for implementation; additional charges may apply) Free Trial: 14-day free trial
Overview Odoo provides a comprehensive suite of business applications, including MRP (Manufacturing Resource Planning) software. It caters to diverse manufacturing needs, covering everything from raw material procurement to final product delivery. Odoo's integrated ecosystem allows businesses to seamlessly plan, schedule, and track their manufacturing operations. However, the flexibility that makes Odoo powerful also adds complexity, making it less ideal for small businesses that need a straightforward, out-of-the-box solution.Key Features
Flexible Manufacturing Management: Adapts to various manufacturing processes with customizable workflows, though setting up these workflows can be time-consuming and costly.
Multilingual Support: Facilitates global operations with support for multiple languages, making it suitable for international manufacturers.
Real-Time Insights: Provides timely data for informed decision-making, although accessing and configuring advanced insights may require expert assistance.
Integrated Business Functions: Combines operations like sales, CRM, inventory, and HR into one platform, which can be overwhelming for businesses that only need a focused MRP solution.
Traceability: Tracks lots or serial numbers throughout the production chain, enhancing quality control and warranty management, but setup for these features can be complex.
Customization & Integration Odoo stands out for its flexibility and extensive customization options, allowing businesses to tailor the system to their specific needs. While this adaptability is a strong point, the level of customization often results in added complexity and increased costs. Businesses looking for a simple, out-of-the-box solution may find Odoo's customization requirements cumbersome and resource-intensive.
Implementation Challenges
Customization Complexity: The high degree of customization available with Odoo can lead to increased implementation time and costs, often requiring the involvement of expert partners or consultants.
Partner Dependency: Implementation often relies on partnering with Odoo experts to ensure smooth integration, which can add to the overall cost and create dependency on external consultants for ongoing changes.
Steep Learning Curve: Even though Odoo offers significant customization, users often struggle to fully leverage its capabilities without dedicated training or expert guidance, which can make the adoption process longer and more difficult.
Customer Support & Service Odoo boasts a large and active community, which can be a valuable resource for users. However, businesses often need to hire partners or consultants for the best support and maintenance. This reliance on external help ensures expert guidance but can also significantly increase the overall costs, making it less appealing for small to mid-sized businesses looking for direct, in-house support.
Pros
Comprehensive All-in-One Platform: Combines multiple business operations, reducing system fragmentation, though it may include features beyond what some manufacturers need.
Extensive App Selection: Offers a wide range of applications to cover various business needs.
Large Supportive Community: The open-source nature provides access to a large community for support and resources.
Competitive Pricing for Initial Adoption: Initially affordable, especially for using just one app.
Highly Customizable: Can be tailored to specific business processes, though customization can be costly and complex.
Cons
Steep Learning Curve: Setting up and using Odoo effectively, especially for complex implementations, requires a significant amount of time and training.
Customization Complexity: The depth of customization can be challenging, leading to increased implementation costs.
Reliance on Partners or Consultants: Businesses often need external support for optimal use and maintenance, adding to ongoing costs.
Hidden Complexity: Initial simplicity may mask the depth of configuration required for full functionality, making it difficult for businesses expecting a quick deployment.
User Feedback Users generally appreciate Odoo for its comprehensive feature set and the ability to manage multiple business functions on a single platform. The system's flexibility and extensive app selection are frequently praised. However, users also highlight the steep learning curve and the significant need for expert assistance to fully leverage its capabilities. The reliance on third-party partners for implementation and customization adds complexity and cost, making it less ideal for those without dedicated technical resources.
The open-source nature and large community are advantages, providing resources and continuous improvements. However, achieving advanced customizations or integrations often turns out to be more complex and costly than initially anticipated. Odoo is powerful but requires careful planning, expert implementation, and ongoing support to fully realize its potential—factors that small and mid-sized businesses may find restrictive.
Odoo is a versatile solution for businesses seeking an integrated and customizable ERP system. However, the level of complexity, reliance on external partners, and the need for substantial customization make it more suitable for businesses with dedicated resources and technical expertise
7. Fulcrum Pro
Pricing: Quote based Implementation: Limited information provided Free Trial: No (Personalized platform tour available)
Overview Fulcrum Pro is a cloud-based manufacturing software specifically designed for OEMs and made-to-order manufacturing environments. It offers a suite of features tailored to meet the unique challenges of custom manufacturing, including job tracking, production scheduling, and inventory management. While Fulcrum Pro provides flexibility for complex custom environments, user feedback suggests that it may be difficult to implement without significant investment in time and resources, making it less suitable for small to medium-sized businesses looking for a straightforward solution.
Key Features
Job Tracking: Provides interactive instructions and live data collection, though setting up these capabilities can be resource-intensive.
Production Scheduling: Offers automated job scheduling to increase throughput, but users report that it can be challenging to configure optimally without expert support.
BOM & Routing: Includes drag-and-drop functionality for creating BOMs and routing, which can be helpful but may require additional training to fully utilize.
Inventory Management: Allows real-time tracking of items throughout the production process, but can be overwhelming for those managing simpler operations.
Quoting and Sales: Facilitates quick and profitable quote generation for custom orders, but may lack the intuitiveness needed for those new to MRP systems.
Customization & Integration Fulcrum Pro boasts over 100 integrations with platforms like Shopify, Shipstation, and QuickBooks Online. Its open API allows for further customization and integration with existing tools, making it highly adaptable to specific business needs. However, these customization capabilities come with added complexity, requiring dedicated technical resources to fully leverage the system.
Implementation Challenges
Data Migration: The process of importing existing data, especially complex BOMs, can be time-consuming and challenging, which makes the initial setup daunting for many users.
Implementation Time: Some users report that implementation takes significantly longer than anticipated, often requiring additional consulting services.
Learning Curve: Advanced features may not be intuitive for less technical users, resulting in extended onboarding times and increased need for training.
Customer Support & Service Fulcrum Pro offers direct phone support from project managers and developers, which is generally well-received by users. However, the effectiveness of support can vary, especially during complex implementations. Unlike Brahmin Solutions, which provides personalized in-house support at every stage, Fulcrum Pro relies on a more generalized approach, which may not always be sufficient for users needing hands-on assistance.
Pros
Supports Unlimited Users: Customizable permission levels make it scalable for growing businesses.
Seamless Integration: Integrates with essential business tools, but the setup can require significant expertise.
Direct Support: Access to project managers and developers is available, but this varies in quality depending on the complexity of the issue.
Highly Scalable: Designed for made-to-order environments, providing flexibility for managing complex manufacturing processes.
Cons
Challenging for Less Technical Users: Advanced features and customization can be overwhelming without dedicated technical expertise.
Lag Between Data Entry and System Updates: Users have reported delays between data entry and seeing those changes reflected in the system.
Slow Load Times: Occasional slow loading can hinder workflow efficiency, particularly during peak usage.
Limited Fit for Standard Manufacturing: The system may be over-engineered for simpler manufacturing operations, making it cumbersome to use.
Basic Reporting: Built-in reporting lacks advanced filtering and customization options, limiting its utility for in-depth analysis.
User Feedback Users generally appreciate Fulcrum Pro for its comprehensive feature set and flexibility in handling custom manufacturing processes. The modern interface and paperless workflow are frequently praised. However, challenges with data migration, extended implementation timelines, and the learning curve for advanced features are common points of frustration. The system's capability to handle complex, made-to-order manufacturing environments is a significant strength, but it may be excessive for simpler manufacturing needs. Fulcrum Pro is a robust solution for OEMs and made-to-order manufacturers willing to invest the time and resources necessary for setup and customization. However, businesses should be prepared for a potentially complex implementation process and ensure they have the technical resources to fully leverage the system's capabilities.
8. Plex Manufacturing Cloud
Pricing: $50,000 - $500,000, with a cost per user of $500 per month Free Trial: No (Demo available) Implementation: $100,000+
Overview Plex Manufacturing Cloud is a comprehensive cloud-based ERP and MES solution designed specifically for manufacturing enterprises. It offers a wide array of features to manage the entire production lifecycle, from shop floor operations to executive-level decision-making. The system is known for providing real-time visibility across manufacturing workflows and optimizing production processes. However, its high costs and complex implementation make it less ideal for small and mid-sized manufacturers seeking a more accessible solution.
Key Features
Inventory Management: Provides accurate, real-time tracking of inventory from receipt to work-in-process to shipment, with lot traceability and barcode integration, though some users report difficulty in navigating the extensive inventory features.
Production Planning and Scheduling: Offers advanced scheduling capabilities that consider work center capacity and available resources to optimize production runs, but can be complex to configure.
Manufacturing Execution: Enables real-time production tracking, quality management, and shop floor control, though the learning curve can be steep for new users.
Financial Management: Includes robust tools for accounting, budgeting, and financial reporting, making it suitable for larger enterprises with complex financial needs.
Customization & Integration Plex Manufacturing Cloud is highly adaptable and can be tailored to meet the specific needs of various manufacturing environments. It integrates seamlessly with many third-party systems, including CAD, CAM, and accounting platforms, which enhances its versatility and functionality. However, achieving this level of customization can be challenging without extensive technical expertise, adding to the overall complexity of the system.
Implementation Challenges
High Implementation Costs: Implementation starts at $100,000+, representing a significant investment that may be prohibitive for smaller manufacturers.
Complex Setup: The extensive feature set leads to a complex and time-consuming implementation process, often requiring dedicated technical staff or consultants.
Learning Curve: Many users report a steep learning curve, especially for less technical staff, making it difficult to realize the full benefits without significant training.
Customer Support & Service Plex's customer support receives mixed reviews:
Limited Direct Support: Some users report difficulties in getting timely assistance for complex issues, especially during critical stages of implementation.
Lack of In-Depth Documentation: Users have noted that the system's documentation could be more comprehensive, which makes it challenging to solve issues independently.
Pros
Modular Design: Facilitates customization and integration with other systems, making it adaptable for different manufacturing needs.
Advanced Analytics and Reporting: Provides valuable insights, though these features may require additional configuration to be fully useful.
Streamlined Workflows and Automation: Can reduce operational costs, though setup is time-consuming.
Robust Security: Ensures data integrity and compliance, providing peace of mind for larger enterprises.
Cons
Inadequate Customer Support: Reported by some users, particularly during the implementation phase.
Limited Mobile App Functionality: The mobile features are not as robust as some competitors, limiting flexibility for on-the-go management.
System Outages: Occasional outages have been reported, which can disrupt manufacturing workflows.
Steep Learning Curve: The system's complexity can make onboarding challenging for new users.
Limited Functionality for Specialized Industries: Not ideal for certain niche manufacturing sectors.
High Upfront Costs: The pricing and implementation costs are significant, making it inaccessible for smaller businesses.
User Feedback Users generally appreciate Plex Manufacturing Cloud for its comprehensive feature set and real-time visibility across manufacturing operations. The system's flexibility and integration capabilities are frequently praised. However, users also highlight the challenges associated with its implementation, the steep learning curve, and occasional performance issues. The high costs linked to implementation and ongoing use are major concerns, particularly for smaller manufacturers. While the system is powerful, achieving full functionality often requires significant setup, customization, and ongoing support.
Plex Manufacturing Cloud is a robust solution for medium to large manufacturing enterprises willing to invest in a comprehensive, cloud-based ERP system. However, businesses should be prepared for a complex implementation process and ensure they have the technical resources needed to fully leverage the system's capabilities.
9. WhereFour
Pricing: Starts at $600 per month Free Trial: No (Demo available) Implementation: Not specified
Overview Wherefour is a cloud-based ERP and traceability software designed specifically for food, beverage, and natural product manufacturing. It offers a suite of features tailored to meet the unique challenges of these industries, including batch management, lot tracking, recipe management, and full material traceability. While Wherefour is robust in handling the specific needs of food production, its industry focus limits its applicability for manufacturers outside these sectors, making it less versatile compared to broader MRP solutions like Brahmin Solutions.
Key Features
Inventory Management: Provides real-time tracking of inventory with lot traceability and barcode integration, though it lacks some advanced features found in more comprehensive MRP systems.
Production Planning: Offers tools for managing recipes, formulas, and batch production, ideal for food manufacturers but potentially limiting for industries with different production needs.
Traceability: Enables full material traceability from raw ingredients to finished products, which is crucial for compliance and quality control.
B2B Portal: Allows customers access to their orders and invoice history, with customizable pricing options, though some users find the invoicing functionalities limited.
Compliance Tools: Helps prepare for audits and ensures regulatory compliance with features like quality assurance functions and document management.
Customization & Integration Wherefour offers integrations with various third-party systems, including QuickBooks, Xero, Sage Intacct, Shopify, and ShipStation. The software's API allows for further customization and integration with existing tools, making it adaptable to specific business needs. However, its customization options are not as extensive as those offered by Brahmin Solutions, which caters to a broader range of industries and offers deeper integration capabilities.
Implementation and Support While specific implementation details are not provided, Wherefour is known for its user-friendly interface and ease of setup. The company offers personalized support and training to help businesses configure the system to their specific needs. However, Brahmin Solutions stands out with its dedicated in-house support team that ensures a smoother onboarding experience, particularly for businesses requiring hands-on guidance during implementation.
Pros
Responsive Support Team: Praised for its responsiveness and helpfulness, although it may not match the depth of dedicated in-house support offered by competitors like Brahmin Solutions.
Strong Traceability Features: Ideal for food production businesses, but limited in scope for industries with different compliance needs.
User-Friendly Interface: Intuitive design that helps streamline processes, though some users still report challenges with onboarding.
Cloud-Based Accessibility: Platform accessible from anywhere, supporting remote work environments.
Cons
Industry Limitation: Primarily focused on food, beverage, and natural products, making it less versatile for manufacturers in other sectors.
Limited Orders/Invoicing and Inventory Functions: Some users have found the order management and invoicing capabilities insufficient for complex requirements.
Lack of In-Depth Documentation: Reported by users who need more comprehensive support for troubleshooting and system setup.
Steep Learning Curve: Despite its user-friendly design, onboarding can still be challenging for some team members, especially in more complex operations.
User Feedback Users generally appreciate Wherefour for its:
Intuitive Interface: Easy to use, which is particularly important for small teams without extensive training resources.
Strong Traceability and Compliance Features: Well-suited for food industry compliance needs, though less applicable for industries with different regulatory requirements.
Responsive Customer Support: Effective but may not provide the depth needed for highly complex issues.
Handling of Food-Specific Manufacturing Needs: Excellent for managing recipes, batch production, and traceability.
However, some users have noted:
The Need for More Comprehensive Documentation: More detailed guides are needed for implementation and troubleshooting.
Limitations in Order Management and Invoicing: Functions that fall short of the requirements of more complex manufacturing operations.
Limited Versatility: The food and beverage focus limits the software's applicability to other industries.
Learning Curve Challenges: Some users find the system challenging to navigate initially, despite its seemingly intuitive design.
Wherefour is a robust solution for food and beverage manufacturers, particularly those prioritizing traceability and compliance. Its cloud-based nature and strong support team make it an attractive option for businesses in these industries. However, its narrow industry focus and limitations in certain functionalities make it less suitable for manufacturers outside the food sector.
10. Unleashed
Pricing: Starting at $349 monthly Free Trial: 14-day free trial Implementation: Starting at $449
Overview Unleashed is a cloud-based inventory management solution designed for businesses of all sizes. It offers real-time inventory tracking, multi-warehouse management, and seamless integration with popular accounting and e-commerce platforms. While Unleashed provides robust inventory control features, it lacks the comprehensive MRP functionalities that manufacturers might need to manage end-to-end production processes effectively. In contrast, Brahmin Solutions offers a more complete set of MRP features, making it the ideal choice for manufacturers looking for an all-in-one solution.
Key Features
Real-time Inventory Control: Provides a perpetual inventory management system that reflects stock positions in real-time across multiple locations, though it may not have the advanced features required for complex production environments.
Product Management: Centralizes inventory information for all sales channels, maintaining up-to-date product records, which is useful but not as extensive as full MRP systems.
Batch and Serial Number Tracking: Offers comprehensive tracking capabilities for product traceability and warranty management, but does not match the depth of traceability offered by Brahmin Solutions for managing both inventory and production batches.
Advanced Inventory Manager (AIM): Automatically detects optimal min-max levels for inventory items based on lead times and usage rates, which is helpful for inventory control but lacks prod
Customization & Integration Unleashed integrates with over 30 cloud-based applications, including Xero, QuickBooks, Shopify, and various CRM systems. It also offers custom API access for further integrations and customizations. However, its customization options are limited compared to Brahmin Solutions, which provides a more comprehensive set of integration and customization tools designed for manufacturers with diverse needs.
Implementation and Support Unleashed is known for its strong customer support, offering personalized onboarding, webinars, guided learning, and comprehensive help files. Implementation starts at $449, which is relatively affordable compared to some enterprise-level solutions. However, Brahmin Solutions stands out with its dedicated in-house support team that guides users through every stage of the process, ensuring a smoother and more efficient onboarding experience without relying on third-party consultants.
Pros
Excellent Integration with Accounting Software: Integrates well with Xero and other accounting platforms, though integration with manufacturing tools is limited.
In-depth Reporting Capabilities: Provides robust reporting features, but customization is limited compared to more advanced solutions like Brahmin Solutions.
Supports Unlimited Warehouses: Offers flexibility for managing multiple locations, which is valuable for businesses scaling their inventory operations.
Strong Supply Chain Costing and Management: Features support effective supply chain management, but without production planning, it falls short as a complete MRP solution.
Top-Rated Customer Support Team: Responsive support that assists users effectively, though the support scope may not be as comprehensive as that provided by Brahmin Solutions.
Cons
Steep Learning Curve: Some users report challenges in learning the system, particularly for more complex inventory setups.
Lacks Production Planning Functionality: The absence of production planning features limits its use as a full MRP solution, making it unsuitable for manufacturers needing complete visibility over the production lifecycle.
No Stock Tracking at Bin Level: Inventory tracking at the bin level is not available, which may be a limitation for businesses requiring more granular inventory control.
Limited Reporting and Customization: Users have reported that the reporting, editing, and search functions can be inflexible, which is a drawback for those needing tailored insights.
Not a Full MRP Solution: Primarily focuses on inventory management, lacking features like production scheduling, which are essential for manufacturers.
User Feedback Users generally appreciate Unleashed for its:
Robust Inventory Tracking Capabilities: Offers effective inventory management across multiple warehouses, though some users desire deeper integration with production processes.
Strong Integration with Accounting Software: Particularly with Xero, making it ideal for inventory-centric businesses.
Comprehensive Reporting Features: Though useful, the lack of customization may hinder some users from obtaining the specific data insights they need.
Effective Warehouse Management: Able to manage inventory across multiple locations, which is advantageous for scaling businesses.
However, some users have noted:
The Learning Curve Can Be Challenging: Especially for those implementing more complex setups or lacking technical expertise.
Lack of Production Planning Features: Limits Unleashed's applicability as a full MRP solution, which can be a major drawback for manufacturers needing an end-to-end system.
Limited Customization of Reports and Search Functions: Constraints on report customization make it challenging to tailor data analysis to specific needs.
Unleashed is a strong choice for businesses primarily focused on inventory management, with excellent integration capabilities for accounting systems like Xero. However, for manufacturers seeking a complete MRP solution that includes production planning, batch management, and deep customization options there are other options on the market.
MRP vs ERP: Understanding the Differences for SMB Manufacturers
Small and medium-sized business (SMB) manufacturers often need to decide between Material Requirements Planning (MRP) and Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems. Both help improve business operations, but they focus on different areas and offer different features.
Material Requirements Planning (MRP) MRP is a software system specifically designed for manufacturing. It focuses on:
Production planning and scheduling
Planning raw material needs
Inventory management
Supply chain management
Key features of MRP for SMB manufacturers:
Managing Bill of Materials (BOM)
Scheduling production and planning capacity
Controlling and optimizing inventory
Forecasting demand
Managing purchase orders
MRP is especially useful for SMB manufacturers wanting to:
Improve production efficiency
Cut costs related to inventory and production
Deliver products on time
Enhance supply chain management
Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) ERP is a complete software system that integrates different business functions, including:
Manufacturing modules (which can include MRP features)
Key features of ERP for SMB manufacturers:
Integrated financial management
Human resources management
Customer relationship management
Advanced reporting and analytics
Multi-site and multi-currency support
Quality management
Project management
ERP is beneficial for SMB manufacturers aiming to:
Streamline all business processes in one system
Improve data visibility across departments
Make better decisions with advanced reporting
Scale operations as the business grows
Comparing MRP and ERP for SMB Manufacturers
Scope:
MRP: Mainly focuses on production and inventory.
ERP: Covers all business operations.
Integration:
MRP: Integrates processes related to production.
ERP: Integrates all business processes.
Cost:
MRP: Generally less expensive, suitable for smaller budgets.
ERP: More expensive, but offers more features.
Implementation time:
MRP: Usually quicker to implement.
ERP: Takes longer because it covers more areas of the business.
Customization:
MRP: Often specialized for manufacturing needs.
ERP: Highly customizable but may require more effort.
Scalability:
MRP: May not grow well as the business expands significantly.
ERP: Designed to grow with your business.
Choosing Between MRP and ERP for SMB Manufacturers
Consider MRP if:
Your main focus is on improving production and inventory management.
You have a limited budget and IT resources.
You need a solution that can be set up quickly.
Your other business processes are relatively simple.
Consider ERP if:
You want to connect all parts of your business operations.
You are planning for significant growth or expansion.
You need advanced reporting across all business functions.
You need one system to manage multiple locations or subsidiaries.
Hybrid Solutions for SMB Manufacturers
Some software providers offer hybrid solutions that combine MRP with some ERP features. These can be a good middle ground for SMB manufacturers who need more than basic MRP but aren't ready for full ERP.
Benefits of hybrid solutions:
More comprehensive than standalone MRP.
Less complex and costly than a full ERP.
Can be scaled up to a full ERP as the business grows.
In Conclusion The choice between MRP and ERP depends on your business needs, budget, and growth plans. MRP is great for focusing on production, while ERP is a complete solution for managing all business areas. Think about your current needs and future goals to decide which system is best for your manufacturing business.
FAQs for MRP Software
How does MRP I differ from MRP II?
MRP I (Material Requirements Planning) focuses on inventory and materials needed for manufacturing based on actual or forecasted customer demand. It helps determine what materials are required, in what quantities, and when they should be ordered. MRP II (Manufacturing Resource Planning) expands on MRP I by providing insight into all manufacturing resources, including production line capacity and workforce capabilities. It also includes financial planning and simulation capabilities, offering greater control over scheduling, forecasting, budgeting, and production processes. Today, MRP II has largely evolved into ERP systems, and standalone MRP I is no longer sold.
Key differences:
Scope: MRP I is limited to materials, while MRP II covers all manufacturing resources.
Functionality: MRP II includes capabilities like financial planning, which MRP I lacks.
Integration: MRP II integrates with other functions like finance and human resources, making it a more holistic solution.
What is the typical implementation time for MRP software? The implementation time for MRP software varies depending on factors like business size, system complexity, customization needs, and company readiness. Typical timelines for SMBs:
Simple Systems: 3-6 months
Moderately Complex Systems: 6-12 months
Highly Customized Systems: 12-18 months These estimates include training, data migration, and process adjustments, and achieving full optimization can take longer.
Is cloud-based MRP software better than on-premises for SMBs?
Cloud-based MRP software offers several advantages for SMBs:
Accessibility: Access from anywhere with internet, ideal for remote or multi-location teams.
Lower Costs: Lower upfront costs compared to on-premises systems.
Scalability: Easily scale without major hardware investments.
Automatic Updates: Cloud providers handle updates and maintenance.
Disaster Recovery: Built-in backup and recovery options. On-premises software may be preferred if:
Data Security Regulations require local storage.
Internet Connectivity is unreliable.
Extensive Customization is needed that cloud solutions can't easily provide.
What should I look for in testimonials or case studies when evaluating MRP vendors?
Look for the following when evaluating testimonials and case studies:
Industry-Specific Examples: Businesses similar in size and industry to yours.
Measurable Outcomes: Reduced lead times, increased production throughput, cost reductions, and improved inventory accuracy.
Implementation Timelines: Details on how long implementation took and any challenges faced.
User Adoption: Ease of use and user adoption rates.
ROI Calculations: Clear return on investment figures.
Problem-Solving Examples: How the MRP solved specific challenges for the business.
Long-Term Success Stories: Experiences of long-term users regarding sustainability and support quality.
What are the relevant MRP software trends for SMBs?
Cloud Adoption: Increased preference for cloud solutions for accessibility and reduced IT overhead.
Mobile Accessibility: Systems with mobile apps for on-the-go management.
AI and Machine Learning: Used for demand forecasting and predictive maintenance.
IoT Integration: Real-time data collection from smart manufacturing equipment.
Advanced Analytics: Improved reporting and visualization for better decision-making.
Sustainability Features: Tools for managing environmental impact and resource efficiency.
Low-Code/No-Code Customization: Customization without needing extensive IT resources.
Integration Capabilities: Seamless connections with e-commerce, CRM, and other business tools.
How can SMBs ensure successful MRP software implementation?
Clear Goals: Define specific objectives for using the MRP system.
Stakeholder Involvement: Engage relevant departments during selection and implementation.
Data Preparation: Clean and format data before migration.
Phased Implementation: Consider a step-by-step rollout rather than a complete overhaul.
Adequate Training: Invest in comprehensive training for all users.
Change Management: Prepare for and manage organizational changes effectively.
Post-Implementation Support: Plan for ongoing support and system optimization.
Regular Reviews: Periodic assessments to ensure the system meets evolving needs.
What are the key features SMBs should look for in MRP software?
Inventory Management: Real-time tracking and optimization of stock levels.
Production Planning & Scheduling: Tools for efficient production processes.
Demand Forecasting: Predict future demand using historical data and trends.
Supply Chain Management: Features to streamline procurement and supplier management.
Quality Control: Tools for monitoring and maintaining product quality.
Reporting & Analytics: Customizable dashboards for data-driven decisions.
Integration Capabilities: Seamless integration with accounting, CRM, and other systems.
User-Friendly Interface: Intuitive design for easy use with minimal training.
Scalability: Ability to grow alongside the business.
Mobile Access: Features accessible via mobile devices.
![The 10 best MRP software on the market [2024]](https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/617b0d62ac72ff62aa032ace/6646dedf1bc8f6427f4148a8_AdobeStock_528806978-min.jpeg)
